Gear Test · Tent Heating · 16-Hour CO Test

Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Review: 16-Hour Carbon Monoxide Test in a Tent

After my video on staying warm while car camping in a tent, the most common question was about carbon monoxide. So I ran a Mr. Heater Portable Buddy on high for about 16 hours inside our REI Kingdom 6, with a digital CO detector sitting right next to it, and checked the reading through the night. Here's the setup, what the detector showed, and why this is one test, not a safety guarantee.

Mr. Heater Portable Buddy heater glowing on a tent floor next to a white carbon monoxide detector

Carbon Monoxide Test: Propane Heater in a Tent (16 Hours)

The full overnight test with the detector on camera at every check-in. Watch on YouTube ↗

Test at a glance

  • Heater: Mr. Heater Portable Buddy, on high
  • Tent: REI Kingdom 6, double-walled with a mesh inner tent; all doors closed overnight
  • Detector: digital CO meter with ppm readout, right next to the heater
  • Run time: about 16 hours
  • CO reading: 0 ppm at every check
  • Propane used: about a quarter of a 20 lb tank

Read this first: this was one test, with one heater, in one double-walled tent with a mesh inner tent. It is not a safety guarantee. Always run a CO detector, keep the tent ventilated, and follow the heater's instructions.

Summary

Over roughly 16 hours with the Portable Buddy on high, the CO detector placed right beside the heater read 0 ppm at the 1-hour check, at about 2 hours, in the evening, and again the next morning. The heater used about a quarter of a 20 lb tank over that time. That's what happened in my setup. Your tent, ventilation, heater condition and hose seal can change the result, so treat this as one data point.

How and Where I Tested It

  • Tent: our REI Kingdom 6, set up the way we normally camp in it, with the heater in one corner. Location: Pacific Northwest.
  • Ventilation: at the start of the video I had a door cracked a little and the mesh at the top, under the rain fly, cracked open. Overnight, all the tent doors were closed. The Kingdom 6 is a double-walled tent with a mesh inner tent, so even with the doors closed it had a lot of airflow.
  • Heater: a Mr. Heater Portable Buddy on a wool blanket, connected to a propane tank with a hose. I checked that the hose connection was firmly sealed to prevent leaks. Tank size: 20 lb.
  • Detector: not a basic beeping alarm, but a CO detector with an LCD screen showing parts per million. Its scale: under 50 ppm is low, 50 to 100 ppm is mid, and above 100 ppm is high. Here is the CO detector I used.
  • Placement: we'd normally sit and sleep away from the heater, but I put the detector right next to it to make the test more sensitive.
  • Power: the plan was medium to full power. At the 2-hour check it was on high, and in the morning it had been at full power for about 16 hours.
  • Recording: a smartphone time-lapse ran the whole time so the detector was on camera.

Results: CO Readings Over 16 Hours

CO detector readings shown on camera in the video
Start0 ppm
About 1 hour0 ppm
1 hr 52 min (about 2 hours, on high)0 ppm
Evening check, about 7:350 ppm
Next morning, about 16 hours at full power0 ppm. About a quarter of the tank used.

Overnight I closed all the tent doors to see whether that would trap any carbon monoxide, and the detector still read zero in the morning. Keep in mind that closed doors didn't make this a sealed tent: the Kingdom 6 is double-walled with a mesh inner tent, so air kept moving. A tent without that airflow could give a very different result.

For how we actually stay warm on cold-weather trips, see my winter tent camping video. These days the family rig runs a diesel heater instead; it's covered on the Ram Rebel + Alu-Cabin page.

Pros and Cons

What I like

  • In my setup, the detector right beside the heater read 0 ppm for the whole run
  • Ran about 16 hours at full power on about a quarter of a 20 lb tank
  • A detector with a ppm readout showed the actual level on camera at every check, not just an alarm

What to know first

  • One test in one tent. It doesn't prove any heater is safe in any tent.
  • Needs airflow, a tight hose seal and a CO detector every time. My tent had a mesh inner tent, so it breathed even with the doors closed.
  • Results depend on your heater, tent and ventilation, so your numbers may differ

Verdict

In this test, the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy didn't register any carbon monoxide on a detector placed right next to it over about 16 hours in an REI Kingdom 6, a double-walled tent with a mesh inner tent, with all the doors closed overnight. That gave me a better understanding of the risk, but it's not a free pass. If you use a propane heater in a tent, take every precaution: make sure the connections are tightly sealed, keep the tent ventilated, run a CO detector, and follow all the heater's directions.

Gear from this test (affiliate links): the CO detector I used · the Mr. Heater Buddy, hose and the rest of my gear in my Amazon storefront.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it safe to use a Mr. Heater Buddy inside a tent?

In my one test, a Mr. Heater Portable Buddy on high for about 16 hours inside an REI Kingdom 6 (all doors closed overnight, but double-walled with a mesh inner tent, so a lot of airflow) never registered any carbon monoxide on a detector placed right next to it. That's one test, not a guarantee. Always ventilate, check the hose seal, run a CO detector and follow the heater's instructions.

How much carbon monoxide did the Buddy heater produce in your test?

The detector read 0 ppm at the start, at about 1 hour, at about 2 hours, in the evening and the next morning after roughly 16 hours.

How long does a Buddy heater run on a tank?

In my test it ran about 16 hours at full power and used about a quarter of a 20 lb propane tank.

Where should the CO detector go when using a heater in a tent?

For this test I put it right next to the heater, closer than where we'd normally sit or sleep, to make the test more sensitive.

What tent did you test the heater in?

Our REI Kingdom 6. Overnight all the tent doors were closed, but it's a double-walled tent with a mesh inner tent, so it still had a lot of airflow.

Does the height of the CO detector matter in a tent?

In this specific test, it didn't. Where the detector sat height-wise didn't change the result. What I can't stress enough is making sure you have good ventilation.

How warm did the Buddy heater keep the tent?

It was definitely warmer inside than outside, but I wouldn't say it was super toasty.

Can you run a propane heater in a fully closed tent?

I wouldn't. With no fresh air coming in there will be oxygen depletion, and the environment may not be safe. The heater needs oxygen to burn, which is why proper ventilation is so important no matter which heater you use. In my test all the tent doors were closed overnight, but it's a double-walled tent with a mesh inner tent, so there was a lot of airflow.

Which CO detector did you use?

Not a basic beeping alarm. I used a CO detector with an LCD screen that shows parts per million. Here's the CO detector I used (affiliate link).

Want the camp rules in a 6-page guide? The Tent Heater & Carbon Monoxide Safety Guide turns this test, plus CDC and manufacturer rules, into a phone-ready PDF: alarms, ventilation, the never-sleep-with-it-on rule, and emergency steps. $2.99.

Get the CO safety guide - $2.99

Keep Exploring

Work With Krokem Outdoors

If you build overland, 4x4 or camping gear and want it tested in real Pacific Northwest rain and snow, the media kit has the details. If a product is reviewed on this channel, you get my honest feedback, good and bad.

Affiliate disclosure: Krokem Outdoors is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Some links on this page go to my Amazon storefront and may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Sponsorships and affiliate links never buy a positive verdict.