40-Inch Tires on Dana 44s: My Jeep Wrangler Rubicon EcoDiesel Build
Can the current-generation Dana 44 axles under a Jeep Wrangler Rubicon handle 40-inch tires? I put 40s on my EcoDiesel Rubicon Unlimited, Dusty, and kept the factory axles. Here's what it took, what it did to fuel economy, and the honest pros and cons.
Bigger Tires (33s to 40s) on Dana 44 Axles: Jeep Wrangler EcoDiesel Build
The lift, axle and gear install, plus MPG and RPM numbers. Watch on YouTube ↗
Trail Testing the 40-Inch Tires: Pros, Cons & Initial Thoughts
The first shakedown run after the lift and tires went on. Watch on YouTube ↗
Why I Went to 40s (and Whether You Should)
I'll say this first: there's no absolute need to go to 40-inch tires. The stock 33s on a Rubicon are enough for most overlanding trails. If you really do need bigger, I'd point most people to 37 or 38 inches.
I went to 40s for two reasons. The first is deep snow. I wanted more clearance to get into the kind of Pacific Northwest snow I like to camp in. The second, honestly, is the look. If that matches your goals, this is what it takes on an EcoDiesel Rubicon.
The Build: Lift, Shocks, Axles and Gears
The work was done at Northridge 4x4 with Tim Lund, who you may recognize from their YouTube channel. The roof rack and bumpers had gone on the week before. For armor and recovery, the Jeep runs Expedition One rock sliders and a Warn winch.
- Lift: Rock Krawler 4.5-inch kit with diesel-rated springs, designed for the extra weight of the JL with the diesel engine.
- Shocks: TeraFlex Falcon shocks.
- Axle shafts: RCV axle shafts up front and Yukon chromoly axle shafts in the rear.
- Gearing: Yukon 5.13 ring and pinion to turn the bigger tires.
- Tires: 40-inch Cooper Discoverer STT Pro, a tire that works across rocks, mud, snow and dirt.
- Wheels: Method beadlock wheels, so I can air down to around 1 PSI in snow with minimal chance of losing a bead.
One detail I liked: Tim showed the stock Rubicon control arm next to the Rock Krawler arm. The Rock Krawler arm is solid all the way through and several times thicker. Its joints rotate far more freely than the factory rubber bushings, which only twist about 15 degrees side to side. That means more articulation in the rocks, and you can torque the arms while the axle is hanging instead of waiting until the Jeep is back on the ground.
Why I Kept the Dana 44s Instead of Going to One-Tons
People ask why I didn't just swap to one-ton axles. It's like asking why I don't buy a Tundra instead of a Tacoma. One-tons cost a lot more, and that wasn't in my budget. Their thicker housings also sit the differentials lower, so I'd lose some clearance, which is the opposite of what I wanted for snow.
The shop's take on the debate was that the current Dana 44s are far stronger than old-school 44s, with big bearings and very efficient ring and pinions. On a relatively light vehicle with low gears and a driver with a light foot, 40s are doable. The key is knowing when to give it wheel speed and when to back off because you're bound up. That's the difference between breaking an axle and not. You can break a one-ton shaft on 40s too.
Fuel Economy and RPM After 40s
This is the part people ask about most. After the install, with the 3.0L EcoDiesel and 5.13 gears, the Jeep was averaging about 17 MPG. That's roughly 5 MPG less than my average on the stock Rubicon tires. At 70 MPH the tach shows a little under 2,100 RPM, compared with a little under 2,000 RPM at 70 on the stock setup.
Keep in mind that beadlocks add a lot of weight to an already heavy tire and wheel. That hurts fuel economy and wears parts faster, so plan on more frequent maintenance and checkups.
First Trail Test on 40s
A week after the install I took Dusty on a shakedown run at a nearby trail. Watch the second video above for that run and the post-run inspection.
If you're building for snow, the printable overland checklist covers the recovery and tire gear I carry, like a deflator, plug kit and traction boards. And if you want to see how this rig compares with my other two, the rig builds section lists all three side by side.
Jeep Rubicon EcoDiesel on 40s: Build Specs
| Vehicle | Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Rubicon (JL), 3.0L EcoDiesel |
|---|---|
| Axles | Factory Dana 44s, kept |
| Lift | Rock Krawler 4.5-inch kit with diesel springs |
| Shocks | TeraFlex Falcon |
| Front shafts | RCV Performance |
| Rear shafts | Yukon chromoly |
| Gears | Yukon 5.13 |
| Tires | 40-inch Cooper Discoverer STT Pro |
| Wheels | Method beadlock wheels, so I can air down to about 1 PSI in snow |
| Armor & recovery | Expedition One rock sliders, Warn winch |
| MPG after install | About 17 MPG average, around 5 MPG less than stock tires |
| RPM at 70 MPH | A little under 2,100, versus a little under 2,000 stock |
| Installed by | Northridge 4x4 |
Pros and Cons of 40s on Dana 44s
What I like
- More clearance for deep snow
- Beadlocks let me air down to about 1 PSI in snow with less risk of losing a bead
- 5.13 gears and diesel torque keep RPM reasonable on the highway
- You keep the factory axles and their clearance instead of paying for one-tons
- Rock Krawler arms flex far more than stock rubber bushings
What to know first
- About 5 MPG lower than my average on stock tires
- Heavy tire and wheel combo means more wear and more maintenance
- The Dana 44s need a light right foot. Driving style decides what breaks.
- Most trails don't need 40s. 33s are enough, and 37s or 38s are the sensible step up.
- Added cost: lift, shafts, gears, tires and beadlocks all at once
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Jeep Wrangler Rubicon's Dana 44 axles handle 40-inch tires?
In my build, yes, with reinforcement and the right driving. I kept the factory Dana 44s and added RCV front shafts, Yukon chromoly rear shafts and 5.13 gears. The current Dana 44s are much stronger than older ones, but you need a light foot and should back off when the drivetrain is bound up.
What gear ratio do you need for 40s on an EcoDiesel Jeep?
I went with Yukon 5.13 gears. With the 3.0L EcoDiesel, the Jeep turns a little under 2,100 RPM at 70 MPH on 40s, compared with a little under 2,000 RPM on the stock setup.
How much MPG do you lose going to 40-inch tires?
After the install my EcoDiesel averaged about 17 MPG, roughly 5 MPG less than my average on the stock Rubicon tires. Beadlock wheels add weight that also hurts mileage.
Should I run 37s or 40s on my Jeep?
Most people don't need 40s. The stock 33s handle most overlanding trails, and 37 to 38 inches is a good size if you need bigger. I chose 40s for deep-snow clearance and the look.
Why not upgrade to one-ton axles instead?
One-tons cost a lot more, which wasn't in my budget, and their thicker housings sit the differentials lower, costing ground clearance. Reinforcing the Dana 44s fit my goals better.
Why run beadlock wheels with 40s?
I run Method beadlock wheels so I can air down to around 1 PSI in snow with minimal chance of losing a bead. The tradeoff is extra weight, which affects fuel economy and wear.
How does stock steering handle 40-inch tires on a Jeep?
It's not bad, but it could be better. On easygoing trails it's fine for now. Steering improvements, like hydraulic assist, are on my list, and I'll pick the option with the best balance of quality and price.
How much did the 40-inch build cost?
It definitely wasn't cheap. I'm not planning a price breakdown because prices change over time, but I include links to the parts so you can check their listed retail prices and add them up.
Did you upgrade the driveshafts for 40s?
Not yet. I'm on the Rubicon driveshafts for the time being, and an upgrade is high on the list once the budget allows.
How heavy are the 40-inch tires?
A little over 100 lb each. Changing one takes a very strong person, two people, or some kind of tire-lifting tool.
How do the Cooper STT Pro tires do in snow?
They're surprisingly grippy on trails and did outstanding in the snow.
Keep Exploring
Work With Krokem Outdoors
If you build overland, 4x4 or camping gear and want it tested in real Pacific Northwest rain and snow, the media kit has the details. If a product is reviewed on this channel, you get my honest feedback, good and bad.
Affiliate disclosure: Krokem Outdoors is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Some links on this page go to my Amazon storefront and may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Sponsorships and affiliate links never buy a positive verdict.